In recent months, the convertible bond market in China has undergone significant volatility, prompting investors to seek refuge in multiple convertible bond exchange-traded funds (ETFs) as they look to capitalize on lower pricingThis shift in investor sentiment reflects a broader trend in the financial markets where participants continually reassess their strategies in response to changing economic conditions.

As of August 30, 2023, the latest market data reveals that the Bosera Convertible Bond ETF has reached a staggering size of ¥17.81 billion (approximately $2.54 billion), marking a growth of over ¥10 billion since the beginning of the year, which translates to an astonishing increase of 183%. Similarly, the Haitong Securities Shanghai Composite Convertible Bond ETF has seen its assets swell to ¥1.71 billion (around $238 million), a remarkable increase of 394% during the same year

Advertisements

Collectively, these two ETFs are nearing the ¥20 billion mark, a significant milestone reflecting the strong appetite for convertible bonds in current market conditions.

The reasons behind the impressive growth in these convertible bond ETFs have been discussed among industry insidersThey point out that the current pure bond premium in the convertible bond market is relatively lowFurthermore, with the equity market clawing its way out of a downturn, convertible bonds have begun to show more attractive risk-adjusted returns compared to traditional credit bondsAt the same time, the inherently diversified and transparent nature of ETFs has led many institutional investors to turn to these products as a way to hedge against risks associated with individual securities.

The past few months have seen convertible bond securities grapple with multiple adverse factors, including downgrades in credit ratings, the potential delisting of certain underlying stocks, and delays in redemption payments for some convertible bond varieties

Advertisements

These factors have influenced market sentiment significantly, particularly following a downturn that began in late MayA record low of 359.94 points for the China Securities Convertible Bond Index was observed on August 23, signifying the lowest point since March 2021. Despite a slight recovery in the subsequent week, the index remains subdued, raising a cautious sentiment among traders and investors alike.

Data from the same timeframe indicates that market participants have increasingly utilized ETF vehicles to enter the convertible bond space, particularly in a bid to purchase at lower pricesThe Bosera Convertible Bond ETF alone saw inflows exceeding ¥4 billion in July—a remarkable surge that coincided with the broader market adjustmentIn fact, since May, the ETF's monthly inflows have consistently exceeded ¥1 billion, demonstrating the growing trend of passive investment strategies in an increasingly unpredictable market environment.

Corresponding with the increased interest in the Bosera ETF, the Haitong ETF has also emerged as a popular choice among investors

Advertisements

Its exquisite performance this year, including a remarkable 394% growth in fund size, resonates with a similar narrative observed with the Bosera product—the collective growth showcases an overall upward movement in confidence towards convertible securities.

As discussions deepen among market experts regarding the recent growth of these ETFs, sentiments have emerged which emphasize the current state of the stock marketInvestors are faced with a dilemma when it comes to traditional equity versus bond investmentsUncertainties surrounding stock fundamentals have led them to favor convertible bonds as an asset class that offers a unique mixture of risk and opportunity—enticing under current trading conditionsMoreover, active convertible bond funds have underperformed over the past couple of years, prompting some investors to favor the passive strategies offered by ETFs.

The cascading effect of increased ETF size has led to improved secondary market liquidity for convertible bonds, encouraging more investors to view this as a prime entry point amid market volatility

• Strengthening the Health Consumer Market
• Japan to Significantly Raise Interest Rates
• New Trends in U.S. Inflation
• Growing Investment in Sci-Tech 50 ETF
• Insurance Capital Boosts Bank Stocks Again

This reflects a broader understanding of investor behavior and a willingness to adapt strategies that minimize risk while seeking growth opportunities.

Furthermore, recent credit risk incidents associated with convertible bonds have led to a fundamental reassessment of market pricing and perceptionsIn this context, investors are now shifting their focus towards diversified products such as ETFs that can mitigate risks associated with individual securities, according to Gao Hui, a fund manager at Bosera Asset Management.

Despite these positives, questions arise regarding the sustainability of passive investments in convertible bonds moving forwardChallenges loom, particularly as the sector grapples with credit risk factors and fluctuating liquidity conditionsIndustry insiders have highlighted key features that characterize successful convertible bond ETFsOne notable aspect is transparency in holdings; unlike actively managed counterparts, ETFs offer investors a clear view of the portfolio and its components, which can be reassuring during times of market instability.

Moreover, the risk diversification strategy stands out as another significant advantage

ETFs utilize optimized replication strategies to minimize exposure to individual securities and industries, thereby enabling investors to navigate the intricacies of convertible bond investments with a measure of confidenceThe careful management of underlying bonds, alongside timely adjustments, further enhances the attractiveness and robustness of these investment vehicles.

On a practical level, the lower fee structures and flexible trading options available through ETFs facilitate a more accessible approach for investors, allowing them to buy and sell on the same day in liquid secondary marketsHowever, in the day-to-day management of these ETFs, challenges do persistFor instance, the presence of certain high premium convertible bonds introduces distinct risks, as their limited market availability can lead to price manipulations—issues that require caution in the selection process to avoid long-term detriments to index performance.

Many investors are aware that credit risk has become an increasingly important pricing component in recent times

Identifying and excluding individual securities with potential default risks can help refine the composition of ETFs, potentially enhancing returns for investors who choose to engage in this marketAdditionally, as product sizes continue to grow, liquidity management remains a persistent challenge, particularly given the generally mediocre liquidity of convertible bondsTransitioning lower liquidity bonds for those with better market conditions can help smoothen operations, while adequate limitations on redemptions might safeguard the integrity of the product during turbulent periods.

Market analysts at Haitong underline that one of the significant upcoming challenges for convertible bond ETFs is the looming decline in bank-issued convertible securitiesAs existing bonds mature, the decrease in supply may trigger fluctuations in asset allocation strategies within the convertible bond space, potentially dampening the performance seen in these ETFs